I went to Mass at a new church today. One which has recently added the extraordinary form twice a month following the promulgation of Summorum Pontificum. Jamie and I decided to do Mass in shifts, so we could both remember what it’s like to be Catholic and look at our missals and spend Mass in a pew (instead of the back of the church, or the bathroom, or outside) and focus on praying and stuff.
The parish I went to was literally just built. In fact, it’s still being built, with more stained glass coming, etc.
The architecture is tasteful, if not entirely classical. It is a far cry better than most of the hideous Catholic architecture found in Northern Virginia. One of the first things I noticed is that the church - which is quite large - was probably about half full. Since this is not the first week with the extraordinary form, I took this as a good sign. By and large, the people look like they’ve never done this before. Their clothing is still the Sunday casual permitted by decades of “God does’t care what you’re wearing to Mass” novus ordo fare. Some looked bored, or distracted. Others were busily trying to find their places in the little red books provided by the parish. The music was, to put it bluntly, awful. (Then again, scholas don’t grow on trees, and female soloists with modern Churchmusik repetoirs do, apparently.)
But the congregation as a whole was quiet, attentive and respectful. There was a sense, on the part of some of the older attendees, of trying to remember.
“We always used to stand during this whole part,” a man whispered to his wife, likely remembering high Mass rather than the low that was offered today.
In line for communion, a woman of about sixty, dressed in a matching red skirt and blazer, was trying to figure out what was going on. She asked an elderly gentlemen at least a decade her senior in front of her (and directly behind me):
Woman: “They let them kneel to receive communion?”
Man: “It’s required.’
Woman: “It is? But why?”
Man: “It’s tridentine. You’re required to kneel and receive on your tongue.”
Woman: “Well, glory be to God!”
Woman (after a pause, and in a quiet, awe-filled voice): “It’s just like it was when I was a kid.”
Man: “Exactly.”
Man (turning around again after a pause of his own): “Which is why you’re also supposed to have something on your head.”
Woman: “Oh no!”
(At which point, she fusses with her shawl, making it quickly into a scarf, which she ties under her chin.)
Woman: “Luckily, I had something I could use!”
It’s one thing to go to a parish that has done the TLM for years, where the people know their prayers and when to sit and stand and kneel. That can be quite comforting, and I admit I prefer it.
But going to a parish like this one and seeing all the potential, that gives me a sense of hope that I don’t get where people have been treasuring the extraordinary form for a very long time.
The beauty of this ancient liturgy being rediscovered by Catholics who perhaps never even knew it was there is what, in my opion, the “New Springtime” really looks like.

